How to write a critique of a peer reviewed article

Image by James Yang http: Todays post offers an alternative perspective; that of the journal article peer reviewer. Doing peer reviews provides important experience for those writing their own papers and may help writers consider what they should include based on what peer reviewers are looking for.

How to write a critique of a peer reviewed article

It can be an honor and a privilege; but it's not ceremonial, it's serious. As critic, you're to pick apart the review paper and outline trouble areas, explaining how they could be better presented. Not only are you to critique the writer's grammar, syntax and style -- concepts with established rules -- you must look at the writer's work from various facets of the big picture, a task fraught with nuance and subjectivity.

Read Critically Check the strength of the paper by reviewing whether the writer's information is concise and consistent, and whether it includes important research data.

How to Critique a Review Paper | Pen and the Pad

The information presented should also be in proper sequence. Also, determine whether the writer's ideas segue smoothly into the conclusion. Look to see if the information provided by the writer is relevant to the subject he's reviewing.

The writer's findings should be coherent and well blended. The information presented by the writer should explain the topic without causing the reader to draw up too many questions. Check to see if the conclusion consolidates the information provided in the body of the review paper.

The conclusion should not introduce new data or results but should provide an ending to the topic discussion. Check the paper for contradictory statements or contradictory elements. Make notations to the writer so he can revisit, clarify or revise.

Double-check any data, evidence or examples provided by the author to make sure the information doesn't contain flaws in interpretation.

Also, determine if the data, evidence or examples support the conclusion or idea. Make sure the evidence provided comes from credible and reliable sources. Ask yourself if you can understand how the evidence relates to the conclusion.

How to Write an Article Review (with Sample Reviews) - wikiHow

Determine whether enough information is presented to accurately arrive at the conclusion. Look for ambiguous phrases and words and think about how they could be clarified.

Instead of just saying something is "wrong," explain why it is and give examples of ways to correct it. Cite this Article A tool to create a citation to reference this article Cite this Article.The difference of how to write a critique and other types of essays comes in the body section and the article format.

Unlike other forms of writing, during the learning process of how to write a critique, you will find that the body of a critique usually has a detailed evaluation of the work, as well as a summary of the article in question.

[BINGSNIPMIX-3

Let’s briefly examine some basic pointers on how to perform a literature review. If you’ve managed to get your hands on peer-reviewed articles, then you may wonder why it is necessary for you to perform your own article critique. questionable!decision!making!on!alower!level.!Udo!Pesch!sees!this!as!“undesirable”!and!writes!

how to write a critique of a peer reviewed article

thatby!carrying!outthe!policies!the!public!administrator!is!at. Whether you are a peer or a teacher, critiquing a review paper is an important duty for you and an important rite in the author's advancement as a writer.

It can be an honor and a privilege; but it's not ceremonial, it's serious.

Critique Paper Peer Review Instructions Write out your answers to these questions, put your partner’s name (labeled “author”) and your name (labeled “reviewer”) on them and give them to your partner. questionable!decision!making!on!alower!level.!Udo!Pesch!sees!this!as!“undesirable”!and!writes! thatby!carrying!outthe!policies!the!public!administrator!is!at. Let’s briefly examine some basic pointers on how to perform a literature review. If you’ve managed to get your hands on peer-reviewed articles, then you may wonder why it is necessary for you to perform your own article critique.

How to Write an Article Critique. Chanelle Sicard. Definition of a Research Paper. Michelle Matthews. How to. questionable!decision!making!on!alower!level.!Udo!Pesch!sees!this!as!“undesirable”!and!writes!

thatby!carrying!outthe!policies!the!public!administrator!is!at.

how to write a critique of a peer reviewed article

When I am doing a peer review, I sometimes do it all in one sitting – which will take me about two hours – or I read it one day and write it the next.

Often, I prefer to do the latter to give myself some time to think about the article and to process my thoughts.

How to Critique a Research Article | Ausmed